In the ever-evolving world of audio production, the line between human creativity and artificial intelligence is becoming increasingly blurred. One area where this is especially noticeable is in the world of music mastering. With the rise of AI-driven music mastering services, artists now have a decision to make: should they opt for a traditional human engineer, or lean into the futuristic world of AI?

Let’s break down the key differences and considerations to help you make the right choice for your next project.

 

1. What’s the Difference Between a Human and an AI Music Mastering Service?

At a glance, both human and AI mastering services aim to achieve the same result — a polished, professional-sounding track. But the process and philosophy behind each approach are vastly different.

AI mastering services rely on algorithms trained on large data sets of professionally mastered music. These systems analyse your track, compare it to similar genres or tonal qualities, and apply EQ, compression, and other effects based on pre-programmed patterns. It’s fast, efficient, and often very affordable.

However, this also means AI lacks a personal touch. It treats your music as data — not as a unique artistic expression. A human mastering engineer, like those at Moreish Studios, listens to your track with emotion and intention. They make creative decisions based on the feeling, genre, and vision of the artist. Every choice — from tonal balance to loudness — is made in context with your sound, not a statistical average.

In short: AI provides generalised precision, while humans offer individualised artistry.

 

2. Are Humans More Expensive Than AI Music Mastering Services?

Yes — human mastering services typically come with a higher price tag. But as with most things in life, you get what you pay for.

Here are some reasons why human mastering is more costly:

  • Non-automated process: Each track is manually analysed and adjusted, which takes time and expertise.
  • Analogue equipment: Many human engineers use specialised analogue gear tailored for mastering, adding warmth, depth, and clarity that AI can’t replicate.
  • Multiple sound system testing: Professionals test your mix on various setups — from studio monitors to car stereos — ensuring your music translates well everywhere.
  • Years of experience: You’re paying for the ears and knowledge of someone who has spent years perfecting their craft. Human mastering is as much about intuition as it is science.

So while AI might be quicker and cheaper, it often sacrifices the depth and detail that only human engineers can bring.

 

3. How Should I Decide on Whether to Use a Human or AI Mastering Service?

Choosing between a human or AI mastering service really comes down to your goals, your audience, and your budget.

Here are a few suggestions to help you decide:

  • Try both on one track: Before committing to a full album or EP, test one track with both services. At Moreish Studios, for example, we offer sample mastering so you can hear the difference for yourself.
  • Think about your audience: Humans listen to your music — not machines. Mastering is about feel as much as it is about fidelity. A human ear understands that nuance and emotional intention, which machines can’t always interpret.
  • Consider your budget: If you’re on a tight budget and AI is the only way your project gets finished, it’s still a valid path. Services like BandLab Mastering or eMastered are worth exploring. But if you’ve already invested so much time, money, and passion into your work, is it worth skimping on the final polish?

Ultimately, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Every artist is different — but quality often comes with a price tag.

 

Conclusion: Finding the Right Fit for Your Music Mastering Service

The choice between AI and human music mastering services is a big one. AI mastering offers speed and affordability, making it a great option for demos or quick releases. But when it comes to depth, emotional connection, and tailored attention — human mastering still reigns supreme.

Whether you go the AI route or choose a hands-on approach from professionals like those at Moreish Studios, what matters most is that your music reaches your audience in the best possible form. After all, great mastering isn’t just about sounding good — it’s about feeling right.